Monday, May 7, 2012


ESPN, Star JV waiting to end By S.DAS Insearchindia.com Team (5 May 2012 11:59 pm) MUMBAI: Rupert Murdoch-controlled News Corp and The Walt Disney Company are deciding on how to end their 16-year-old sports broadcasting joint venture in India. Star Group wants to buy out ESPN's stake in the equal joint venture so that it gets independent control to expand its sports broadcasting business in India at a time when acquisition costs have climbed to astronomical heights. Star's ability to take risks and aggressively mop up cricket rights would be higher as it can leverage the sports property with its highly popular entertainment channels in India. "Star is very keen on buying out ESPN's 50 per cent stake in India. The JV is under severe strain and the individual business interests of the two companies can no longer be served by it," a source familiar with the development said. Star TV, for example, scooped up media rights to international cricket played in India from the BCCI for a whopping Rs 38.51 billion from 2012 through to 2018. The JV, which has the ICC rights ($1.1 billion for eight years from 2007-15) and the Champions League Twenty20 ($975 million for 10 years), was not agreeable to bid so high. "Star was ready to pay so high as it served its business interests. It wanted to deny Sony (which bid Rs 37 billion) the rights as, along with the IPL, it would have become a formidable network. The entertainment channels have already started delivering for Sony. Star could bid that amount because of its overall India strategy," the source said. The problem is that neither Star nor Disney want to sell out. ESPN has also expressed interest to buy out Star's stake in India, the source said. "It could have been easier if it would have been any other multinational media company like Turner International. Disney has also made serious investments in the Indian market. It has bought out UTV Software Communications and has delisted it. It has got an aggressive person in Ronnie Screwvala to head its India operations. While having a presence in kids, niche entertainment channels and movies, it is missing in the Hindi GEC (general entertainment channel) space which is massive in India. It also wants to have full control of sports broadcasting," the source said. For any partner to sell the India business would mean that it would be locked out of sports for a few years due to a non-compete clause. "Neither Disney nor Star want to be out of this lucrative business for a few years as there would be a non-compete clause. Besides, there are few cricket rights available and they are all locked long term," the source said. Cricket is the only sporting property that people watch at a mass level with passion across the country. It has got both advertising and pay revenue pull. The IPL is the richest property, with Sony earning ad revenue of Rs 9 billion last year. In 2011, sports broadcasters raked in advertising revenue of Rs 20 billion. Digitisation also throws open a wide pay revenue potential. The complexity of the issue is obvious as the web of the JV spreads across Asia. The talks for a split started a year back and even discussed about the possibility of News Corp letting go rest of Asia to ESPN. "FIC (Fox International Channels) runs a business worth over $1 billion in rest of Asia and does not want to let go of sports. That is not possible," the source said. Splitting the properties that the JV holds is also not feasible. "The only way they can terminate the joint venture is by somebody selling out. This will also make the task of valuing the assets easier," the source said. Star holds an upper hand at this stage as it has got the BCCI rights. It has sub-licensed the rights to ESPN Software India, the joint venture company which runs ESPN Star Sports' India operations. "The weight of the Rs 38.51 billion property is hanging overhead. The JV will be given the task of monetising it so long as the partnership lasts," the source said. The BCCI property also leaves Star with another option to explore. In the worst case scenario if it decides to sell out to ESPN, it can build a sports broadcasting business with the BCCI rights as the starting pillar, much like Sony did with the Indian Premier League (IPL) or Nimbus did with BCCI (though Neo couldn't hold on and had to forego the BCCI rights). "Star would ideally like to buy out ESPN's stake in the JV to get full control of India before the first series (from the BCCI rights) kicks off between India and New Zealand in August," a media observer said. Disney may decide to first focus on consolidating its UTV investments and building the Hindi GEC vertical as well before it goes all out on sports. At least that is what Star would like Disney to do. The cricketing rights are spread among the four broadcasting companies. The ESPN-Star JV has rights to ICC, Champions League Twenty20, England and Australia cricket boards. Ten Sports, owned by Zee Group, has rights to the five boards - Pakistan, Sri Lanka, West Indies, South Africa and Zimbabwe. It recently renewed Cricket South Africa (CSA) rights for $180 million and Zimbabwe for $20 million (both for eight years). Sony has New Zealand and IPL while Neo has Bangladesh. India may not be the only market where News Corp will be wrestling against ESPN. Media reports indicate that News Corp will be launching a national sports network on cable television to take on ESPN in the US. News Corp has snapped up various sports rights, prominent among them being the US TV rights to Fifa World Cup in 2018 and 2022, beating ESPN in the race. It has also secured rights to the Pac-12 Conference and Big-12 Conference games and is in the running to secure an exclusive deal with Los Angeles Dodgers. "ESPN Star Sports will telecast the New Zealand series. Star will sub-license the BCCI rights to the JV so long as the divorce does not take place," the source said.

Wednesday, May 2, 2012

News broadcasters decry carriage fee in new tariff order Insearchindia.com Team ( 2 May 2012 4:57 pm) NEW DELHI: The News Broadcasters Association (NBA) has expressed its shock and dismay at the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India's tariff order for digital addressable systems as it has legitimised carriage fee that has deeply hurt their profitability. NBA has that the Notification has 'legitimized' the very practice the NBA had hoped would be ended - the payment of steep "carriage fees" by broadcasters. It noted that the primary purpose of digitisation was to increase the number of channels that can be broadcast. The objective was to give consumers greater choice and to eliminate the phenomenon of "carriage fees", which were being charged due to capacity constraints. However, the NBA was distressed and disappointed that Trai's new Notification had actually legalised the practice of "carriage fees" and given distributors the freedom to unilaterally set the amount of "carriage fees" broadcasters must pay. "This unfairly penalises broadcasters and threatens the very survival of the broadcasting industry," NBA said, urging the government and Trai to look into this malaise and correct it urgently. News broadcasters will be meeting the I&B ministry and Trai to express their grievances.
Star to launch Movies Ok on 6 May By J.FAROOQUI Insearchindia.com Team (30 April 2012 11:59 pm) MUMBAI: Movies Ok, the second channel from Star India under the 'Ok' banner, is being readied for launch on 6 May coinciding with the start of the Aamir Khan show Satyamev Jayate. Star, the parent company of Movies Ok, had earlier rebranded its youth-focussed Hindi general entertainment channel Star One as Life Ok, giving it a distinct content identity after its new launch. Movies Ok will be positioned as a family movie channel and will be headed by Star Gold general manager Hemal Jhaveri with a separate team being carved out for it. "We are launching Movies Ok on 6 May. It is being positioned as a family movie channel and will complement Star Gold," Jhaveri tells Insearchindia.com. The company is still in the process of finalising a carriage deal with cable and DTH operators. The channel will be free-to-air to begin with. "The clear cut differentiation will be the way one treat's content and Movies Ok will be packaged differently from Star Gold. We have a library of over 1000 movies. A typical operator of a movie channel needs at least 250 movies to run it," says Jhaveri. The new channel will be promoted during Star's ambitious show, Satyamev Jayate. Star will also use radio and digital platforms. "Specialisation is the way forward for Hindi movie channels. If you look at it, globally there are several genres like family, action, horror and so. We will promote the movie channel on the show Satyamev Jayate," Jhaveri adds. Hindi movie channels enjoy a 16 per cent share in the CS4+ TG Hindi Speaking Market, as per a Tam report titled 'Impatient Generation'. Services, auto, personal accessories and telecom are some of the categories that spend heavily on Hindi movie channels. The ad revenue market for the genre is pegged at Rs 8 billion and is expected to grow 15-20 per cent this year.
100 FTA channels for Rs 100; Minimum Rs 150 for FTA & Pay channels: Trai Insearchindia.com Team ( 2 May 2012 6:55 am) NEW DELHI: Tevision viewers will be able to get a minimum 100 free-to-air (FTA) channels at a maximum retail price of Rs 100, or pay a minimum Rs 150 per month for a la carte choice that may include pay as well as FTA channels. This has been specified in the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services (Fourth) (Addressable Systems ) Tariff (first amendment) Order 2012, issued exactly a month after its own announced date of 31 March by the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (Trai). Basic Service Tier According to the regulatory framework for Digitalised Cable TV brought out by Trai "to safeguard consumers' interests", cable operators will have to mandatorily offer a Basic Service Tier (BST) to viewers throughout the country that will consist of 100 FTA channels including 18 mandatory Doordarshan channels and the Lok Sabha channel. Under the order, cable operators and multi-system-operators (MSOs) have to ensure that there are a minimum of five channels of different genres. The genres which Trai has named are General Entertainment Channels (GECs) in English, Hindi, Regional, Music, News, Movies, Sports, Kids Infotainment, and lifestyle. "The BST shall be mandatorily offered by the cable operator. However, it will be optional for the consumer to subscribe," Trai said. Consumers can choose a la carte FTA channels also. The broadcast sector regulator also said that in case customers choose some option beyond the BST which includes some pay channels, a minimum monthly price up to Rs 150 would be paid. "If the total value of the channels/ bouquets opted by the subscriber exceeds Rs 150, only then actual subscription charges has to be paid," Trai said. Trai has also issued the The Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations 2012. While the Tariff Order has been issued as an amendment to the existing Tariff Order for addressable systems, dated 21 July 2010, the Interconnection Regulation is comprehensive one for the Digital Addressable Cable TV Systems. These rules will come into force along with the digitisation of the cable sector for which the government has already set up a deadline of 30 June this year in the four metros and December 2014 for the entire country. Trai's latest tariff order has also laid down rules on the basis of which channels and bouquets will be priced. All channels will have to be made available individually or on an a la carte basis that will ensure viewers will have the choice to take only the channels they want. Trai has mandated that the rate of a single channel should not exceed three times the average channel rate of the bouquet. So, if on an average, a channel has been priced at Rs 3 by the cable operator, he cannot charge more than Rs 9 per channel in that bouquet. MSOs to carry minimum of 500 channels from 1 Jan 2013 The Authority has mandated MSOs to carry a minimum of 500 channels from 1 January 2013. However as MSOs having less than 25000 subscribers may need some additional time for building the capacity, they have been given time up to 1 April 2013. To ensure that the consumer is not adversely affected, the Authority has prescribed that every MSO should have a minimum capacity to carry 200 channels from 1 July 2012. The Authority asked all the MSOs operating in areas of Phase-II onwards to take suitable measures to enhance the channel carrying capacity to 500 channels. The Authority has ordered that from 1 January next year, all cable operators must carry Hindi, English, and channels in the regional language of the area concerned. Carriage Fee While not doing away with the carriage fee as demanded by broadcasters, Trai said it will have to be charged in a non-discriminatory and transparent fashion. All channels will be charged uniformly and the MSOs will have to file the fees with Trai. There is also a provision mandating that the regulator will intervene if carriage fees is found to be unreasonable. Keeping in view the fact that substantial investment for implementation of Digital Addressable Cable TV Systems is made by the MSO and the cost involved in carriage of channels, the Authority has decided that every MSO may fix the Carriage Fee. However, it should be published in the Reference Interconnect Offer and applied in a uniform, non-discriminatory and transparent manner. The Carriage Fee cannot be revised upward for a minimum of two years. The Authority would intervene in case it is felt that the Carriage Fee is unreasonable. The MSOs can fix the retail tariff and also package and price offerings. However, the sum of the a la carte rates of channels, forming part of a bouquet, shall not exceed 1.5 times the rate of the bouquet. Further, the a la carte rate of any channel shall not exceed three times the average channel rate of the bouquet. The number of TV households in India is estimated to be around 147 million. The cable industry has grown from 0.4 million cable homes in January 1992 to an estimated 94 million cable TV homes in 2011 with more than 800 registered channels. Of these, around 160 are pay channels. There are a large number of channels which are transmitted as FTA channels. Trai says the basic purpose of digitisation is to ensure ample choice to the consumer as well as to enable him to budget his subscription according to his paying capacity. Must Carry Provision Trai has also prescribed the 'must carry provision'. This means that MSOs will have to carry the channels. Only those MSOs that have the requisite capacity, as mentioned above, can invoke 'must provide' clause. The broadcasters shall not provide their channels to MSOs who have channel carrying capacity of less than 200 channels immediately and less than 500 channels from 1 January 2013 or 1 April 2013 in case of smaller MSOs. The provision relating to amount charged by broadcaster to MSO remains unchanged. They can charge a maximum of 42 per cent of the rate they charge in the non-addressable systems. Revenue share between MSO & LCO The July 2010 Tariff Order provides that the revenue share between the MSO and LCO shall be based on mutual negotiations. The Authority has now prescribed that in case the mutual negotiations fail, the revenue share shall be in the ratio of 55:45 (MSO: LCO) for BST or FTA channels. The revenue share for Pay channels or bouquet of Pay channels with or without FTA channels shall be in the ratio of 65:35 (MSO: LCO). Trai said, "Implementation of Digital Addressable Cable TV Systems (DAS) will lead to better choice to consumers, variety and quality of content, adequate revenue to stakeholders and healthy environment for the industry in addition to bringing in transparency in the business transactions and subscriber base. It would also ensure that the Government receives the due revenue." Ad-free channels Referring to viability of ad-free channels, Trai said a large majority of the stakeholders, consisting of all the segments including the consumers, are of the view that the determination of viability of the ad-free channels in the Indian markets be left to the market forces to decide. On the issue of tariff dispensation for the ad-free channels, "a large majority of the stakeholders have advocated forbearance at both the wholesale and retail levels in the DAS areas. Some MSOs have, however, suggested that the wholesale tariff be regulated, keeping the retail under forbearance whereas one cable operator association has suggested that tariff for ad-free channels should be regulated by Trai." As far as the sharing of the subscription revenue of the ad-free channels is concerned, all the broadcasters have said it should be left for the commercial negotiations between the service providers. The other stakeholders are divided over this issue. Some of these stakeholders have suggested that revenue share be decided in the same way as any other pay channel while others have suggested different percentages for broadcaster, MSO and LCO. However, they have not offered any justification for the same. Offering of a channel in advertisement-free format (Ad-free channel) is a recent phenomenon in the Indian television market. These channels are driven by demand and generally cater to targeted segment of viewers. The ad-free channels, being solely dependent on the subscription revenue and demand based, in line with the view of a large majority of the stakeholders, the Authority has decided to keep the ad-free channels under complete forbearance. The niche channels, for example. HDTV channels and 3D channels - which require specialised STBs, are already under forbearance and would continue to remain under forbearance. The Authority will review the position at an appropriate time. As far as revenue share is concerned, it shall be shared between MSO and LCO in the same ratio as defined for other channels.

Thursday, April 26, 2012


IPL's ratings make it tough for Max to post ad rev growth Insearchindia.com Team (25 April 2012 11:37 pm) MUMBAI: The fifth season of the Indian Premier League is settling down to lower ratings than its previous edition, making it tough for Multi Screen Media to protect its ad revenue of Rs 9 billion from the telecast of the event on Max. The first 27 matches of the IPL have garnered a viewership of 3.53 TVR compared to 3.88 TVR a year ago, according to Tam data (for CS4+ TG, All India market). The cumulative reach has also gone down from 140 million last year to 137 million. Despite improvement in competitiveness with several close finishes, the ratings for the IPL have gone down. For the first seven matches, the viewership was 3.76. This further fell to average TVR of 3.65 for 16 matches. The IPL, however, continues to be a profitable property for MSM and cricket's highest revenue earner. “Media may file whatever they want to, but if you look at the top 10 programmes you will get your answer,” said IPL CEO Sundar Raman. According to GMR Sports marketing head Hemant Dua, the drop in viewership is a natural progression in the life of a sporting league. He also believes that people have unfair expectations from the IPL. “I think the IPL is maturing as a league and there will be times when the ratings will plateau a bit or will increase but overall the IPL has done well this season and attendance for matches has been good. The expectation from the IPL is high but one should understand that the ratings are strong enough," said Dua. The fragmentaion of the Indian media landscape has not helped the IPL to better its ratings this year. According to MEC South Asia COO Shubha George, the IPL ratings have been in line with expectations.“We had predicted a drop in viewership, but if you look at the ratings they are still better. After all, which property will give you a viewership of 3.5 TVR and a pan-India reach,” he said. MSM has, however, stayed firm in not dropping the rates as it fears that it will make it difficult to up the rates next year if the benchmark is set low this time. Max has six sponsors on board who are forking out between Rs 450,000-500,000 per 10 second spot. The broadcaster has managed to sell only 70 per cent of inventory with a large part of the FCT being used for self-promotion. Attempts to reach MSM president network sales, licensing & telephony Rohit Gupta proved futile till the time of filing this report. For MSM to substantially boost its ad revenues from the IPL, ratings will have to improve. “They won’t command a premium on average rating of 3.5. But the IPL as a property still remains a valuable proposition," said a media analyst who did not want his name to be revealed.

MSOs divided on Trai’s ad regulation policy Insearchindia.com Team (25 April 2012 10:13 pm) MUMBAI: Trai’s ad regulation proposal has divided two of the country’s leading multi-system operators (MSOs) into opposite camps with Digicable coming out in support while Hinduja Ventures-owned operator IndusInd Media and Communications Ltd opting for a no-regulation line. The regulator had initiated the policy to regulate ads on a clock hour basis on the premise that the country is moving towards digitisation and subscription income will become the primary source of revenue stream for broadcasters, an argument which the broadcasters have trashed outright. However, Digicable in its response to Trai’s consultation paper ‘Issues Related to Advertisements in TV Channels’ has suggested the cap to be only 10 minutes (eight minutes for commercials and two minutes for self-promotion) instead of 12 minutes proposed by Trai for FTA channels. For pay-channels, Digicable favours a cap of eight minutes (six minutes for commercials and two minutes for self-promotion) while it is against allowing commercials on HD channels except for two minutes in a clock hour. “If the broadcaster agrees to have a 100 per cent advertisement free channel, then he can have total forbearance on the subscription rate charged for that channel,” Digicable said. It also demanded that certain channels which are presently FTA in digital domain but pay in analog should be treated as pay till they have a uniform status across the country. IIMCL, on the other hand, favoured a more open market policy where consumers must be allowed to decide whether they want an ad-free channel or a free to air channel subsidised by advertisements. “It is up to the subscriber to opt to watch a channel with advertisements at a lower cost or pay premium to watch a channel without ads. Broadcasters on the other hand will automatically regulate the ad time as too many ad breaks will drive away subscribers, thus affecting their resources,” IIMCL said. Both the MSOs were in agreement that in case of sporting events, advertisements should be carried only during disruptions as most of the sportscasters are pay channels with certain sports like cricket being monetised heavily. In the case of News and Current Affairs channels, the two operators agreed on Trai’s proposal to run not more than two scrolls at the bottom of the screen and occupying not more than 10 per cent of the screen space for carrying non-commercial scrolls and tickers. The audio level of the advertisements should also not be higher than the audio level of the programme, both Digicable and IIMCL held. Stressing that India is not a pay market as consumers do not pay for content, Cable Operators Federation of India is of the view that the so called pay channels were introduced in India in an illegal way in the non-addressable networks by forcing cable operators to pay to receive them, once they became popular as FTA channels. For the last 18 years pay channels have been exploiting the cable operators using all unethical ways like blackmailing with threats of a black out, arbitrary increase in rates, forcing bouquets on consumers and making cartels for distribution. Cofi wants FTA channels to get 12 minutes ads in a clock hour and pay channels not to be allowed to carry any ads as they would get 100 per cent subscription in the digital regime. The cable association did not favour allowing ads in sports channels as they already charge the highest amount amongst all pay channels. It also agrees to permitting only full screen ads and not more than two scrolls at the bottom of a page for news and current affairs channels.

Thursday, April 19, 2012

IPL 5 ratings soften, 16 matches notch up 3.65 TVR


Insearchindia.com Team

(18 April 2012 11:35 pm)


MUMBAI: The ratings for the fifth season of the Indian Premier League have failed to improve after a softer opening, while it has started eating into the Hindi general entertainment genre.

The first 16 matches of the IPL have registered an average TVR of 3.65 compared to a 4 TVR in the last season of the tourney.

As per data from TAM Sports, the cumulative reach of the matches (C&S, 4+, All India) have dropped to 123 million viewers, from 127 million last time.

The first seven matches of the current IPL season had delivered an average rating of 3.76 TVR which was lower than the 4.63 TVR that it had notched up last year.
Multi Screen Media (MSM) president network sales, licensing and telephony Rohit Gupta declined to comment on whether the channel would manage to achieve growth this year. In the fourth edition of the IPL, MSM had posted an advertising revenue of Rs 9 billion.


For the record, the broadcaster has only six sponsors on board with Vodafone and Idea 3G smart phone as co-presenting sponsors and Cadbury's Dairy Milk, Havells, Pepsi and Tata Photon as associate sponsors.

GroupM CEO South Asia Vikram Sakhuja says that re-calibration of rates is needed. "The IPL is still a very good property and it is maturing. The first week's data was around 10-11 per cent less than last year. The second week's ratings are almost similar to what was managed last year.

Overall, so far the ratings are six to seven per cent lower. I think that the event could manage a similar performance to last year with a possible positive or negative difference of four to five per cent. Even with properties like 'KBC' you see a bit of a drop from one season to the next. What you hope for is that the ratings at least hold steady."

He notes that one good thing about this edition of the IPL is that there have been more close encounters compared to last year. "Both of yesterday's matches went down to the wire. That should help viewership."

More micro-marketing efforts are needed at this stage of the event. "This means building anticipation for daily clashes and better marketing of day to day matches is needed. This effort needs to come from everybody including the broadcaster and franchises," Sakhuja says.

Commune Sports and Entertainment MD Jamie Stewart continues to stay bullish on the IPL. "Although the ratings have dropped, I think the IPL is still a valuable property. Even at the current level, the rating is decent."

Stewart believes the franchises should not have upset the applecart by revamping their teams as that leads to dilution in fan loyalty. "I think the change in teams last year was complete madness as many of the franchises had to start building their fan base right from the scratch," he adds.